| Queen | Fair or Festival | Year |
| Margaret Ann Tinsley | Magnolia Fair | 1958 |
| Ann Drane | 1959 | |
| Kay Frances Seelinger | Nicholas County Fair | 1960 |
| Violet Stockwell | Clay County Fair | 1961 |
| Linda Kay Bennington | Clay County Fair | 1962 |
| Sherry Lee Shortridge | Logan County | 1963 |
| Carolyn Falkenstein | Monongalia County Fair | 1964 |
| Betty Heatherman | Tri-County Fair | 1965 |
| Judy Collins | Tri-County Fair | 1966 |
| Pamela Ann Brown | Taylor County Fair | 1967 |
| Beverly Beavers | Monongalia County Fair | 1968 |
| Pamela Dean | Taylor County Fair | 1969 |
| Patty Cline | Tyler County Fair | 1970 |
| Jo Debra Gilford-Gandee | WV Strawberry Festival | 1971 |
| Leslie Ann Buck | Tyler County Fair | 1972 |
| Monica Lewandowsky | Paw Paw District Fair | 1973 |
| Beverly Ratliff | Monongalia County Fair | 1974 |
| Erma Lynn Fridley | Mason County Fair | 1975 |
| Deborah Suder | Paw Paw District Fair | 1976 |
| Beverly Williams | Paw Paw District Fair | 1977 |
| Debbie Wilkinson | Kanawha County Fair | 1978 |
| Tanya Jones | Lincoln County Tobacco Fair | 1979 |
| Marta McClure | Lincoln County Tobacco Fair | 1980 |
| Cynthia Baniak | Monongalia County Fair | 1981 |
| Julia Ralston | WV Strawberry Festival | 1982 |
| Janie Sebert | Nicholas County Potato Festival | 1983 |
| Wendy Welty | Three Rivers Coal Festival | 1984 |
| Cindy Walsh | Monongalia County Fair | 1985 |
| Sally Dawn Lambert | Three Rivers Coal Festival | 1986 |
| Leah Lasker | Rocky Top Mountain Festival | 1987 |
| Kimberly Warner | WV Oil & Gas Festival | 1988 |
| Vickie Myers | Parkersburg Homecoming Festival | 1989 |
| Shannon Sprague | WV Dandelion Festival | 1990 |
| Eisa Krushansky | Monongalia County Fair | 1991 |
| Brandy Glover | WV Interstate Fair | 1992 |
| Tina Cutlip | WV Oil & Gas Festival | 1993 |
| Jodi Livingston | Tyler County Fair | 1994 |
| Lucy Ours | WV Interstate Fair | 1995 |
| Anissa Hinkle | Nicholas Co Potato Festival | 1996 |
| Tara Wilson | WV Nurserymens Association | 1997 |
| Jennifer Petroff | Chapmanville Apple Butter Festival | 1998 |
| Elizabeth Taylor | Clay County Golden Delicious Festival | 1999 |
| Jessica Wilson | WV Strawberry Festival | 2000 |
| Jennifer Haynes | WV Interstate Fair & Exposition | 2001 |
| Kasey Montgomery | Tri County Fair | 2002 |
| Rachael Walters | Buffalo Octoberfest | 2003 |
| Christina Lankford | WV Strawberry Festival | 2004 |
| Jessica Holley | Beckley Kids Classic Festival | 2005 |
| Stacy Pudder | Mannington District Fair | 2006 |
| Talia Markham | Lincoln County Fall Festival | 2007 |
| Heather Hostutler | WV Strawberry Festival | 2008 |
| Jillian Wedge | Parkersburg Homecoming Festival | 2009 |
| Kayla May | WV Fourth of July | 2010 |
| Miranda Ferrari | WV Strawberry Festival | 2011 |
| Caitlin Sharp | WV Dandelion Festival | 2012 |
| Nichole Green | WV Oil & Gas Festival | 2013 |
| Leslie Garrett | WV Black Walnut Festival | 2014 |
| Alexis Farmer | WV Dandelion Festival | 2015 |
| Emily Lopez | WV Oil & Gas Festival | 2016 |
| Jocelynn Wilson | Point Pleasant Battle Days | 2017 |
| Makeia Raine Jonese | Barboursville Fall Fest | 2018 |
| Alexis Bland | WV Interstate Fair & Exposition | 2019 |
| Breanna Pekula | WV Winterfest | 2020 |
| Breanna Pekula * | WV Winterfest | 2021 |
| Brennah Groves | Nicholas County Potato Festival | 2022 |
| Bridgette Altizer | WV Cupcake Festival | 2023 |
| Alyssa Lilly | WV Oil & Gas Festival | 2024 |
| Sophia Wigal | WV Black Walnut Festival | 2025 |
Page last updated on January 12 at 9:00 AM – WVAFF Tech
